Meet All About Romance Reviewer

 AAR Home   Masthead   Reviews Page 

Lynn Spencer

 

Editor/Senior Reviewer/Ombudswoman

About Me


Like the other reviewers here, I have spent most of my life (28 years so far) sitting behind the covers of a book and thus traveling across time and around the world. I've loved historical fiction and mysteries since I was a child, and as I got older, my mother let me read some of her romantic suspense and gothic novels. Summer afternoons spent poring over Victoria Holt, Mary Higgins Clark and Phyllis Whitney novels opened up a new world for me of heroines who could have fun, go through all manner of adventures, and fall in love.

In high school I discovered historicals and traditional regencies at camp. I was put off at the time (and still am, on occasion) by the “clinch” covers on many novels, so I did not venture far beyond the world of Harlequin Historicals and the occasional discreet stepback until I discovered Roberta Gellis’ Roselynde Chronicles my last year in college. After that discovery, my time spent haunting used bookstores increased exponentially.

Today, I am an attorney in the Washington DC metro area, a place rather far removed from the Virginia mountains where I grew up. I still have very eclectic reading tastes, but prefer historicals, romantic suspense and mystery novels on the whole. Nonfiction books on history and politics, gothic novels and regencies also take up plenty of space in my TBR pile, though. I love reading, writing and generally chatting about books with people, so I welcome the chance to be a reviewer at AAR. When I’m not working or reading, I enjoy hiking, surfing the internet and goofing off with my two beloved cats.

Personal Reading Tastes


What I'm a sucker for in a book:


"Different" settings (i.e. not England or the Old West), especially Russia/Eastern Europe, the 16th-18th centuries, long, meaty historicals loaded with period detail, characters who grow and change throughout a book, a touch of mystery or the supernatural, characters outside of the usual lord/lady/cowboy rut, witty repartee, strong secondary characters, gothics, and first-person point of view.

What I don't particularly care for in a book:


“Wallpaper” history (unless it’s a good comedy), bedroom doors thrown too far open, the obligatory baby-studded epilogue, the insistence on shorter novels (I realize this is more an editor quirk than an author quirk but I still don’t like it), amnesia, overly cutesy titles, falling in love with the boss plots, and I-hate-you-no-I-love-you plots.

What drives me absolutely nuts in a book:


Shoddy historical research/lots of historical errors, lust dressed up as love, one person daring the other person to kiss him or her, heroines who keep trying to run away from the hero, romances at improbable/inappropriate times (i.e falling for some hunk when your beloved husband is barely cold in the ground), characters who have a “burgeoning” anything , Dukes of Slut, “child” heroines, “Taming of the Shrew” plots, spineless, and “clinging vine” heroines (especially if they’re supposed to be leaders or professionals). .

Favorite Romance Authors


Favorite Romance Authors


  • Julia Quinn
  • Nora Roberts
  • Roberta Gellis

    Best Discovery/Buried Treasure Authors


  • Bronwyn Williams (historicals only)

    My Biggest Glom


  • Julia Quinn
  • Cynthia Harrod-Eagles

  • Favorite Characters


    Favorite Hero


  • Christy Morrell, To Love and To Cherish by Patricia Gaffney

    Favorite Heroine


  • Penelope Featherington, Romancing Mr. Bridgerton by Julia Quinn
  • Augusta Ballinger, Rendezvous by Amanda Quick

    Most Tortured Hero


  • Charles Fraser, Daughter of the Game by Tracy Grant
  • Gideon Westbrook, Ravished by Amanda Quick

    Strongest Heroine


  • Melanie Fraser, Daughter of the Game by Tracy Grant
  • Augusta Ballinger, Rendezvous by Amanda Quick

    Favorite Couple


  • Penelope Featherington and Colin Bridgerton, Romancing Mr. Bridgerton by Julia Quinn
  • Charles and Melanie Fraser, Daughter of the Game by Tracy Grant

  • Least-Favorites


    Most Disappointing Book


  • The Inheritance by Joan Johnston

    Worst Book


  • All the Sweet Tomorrows by Bertrice Small
  • Amarantha by Melanie Jackson

    Book with Most Purple Prose


  • Anything by Cassie Edwards

    Authors I Have Given Up On


  • Patricia Gaffney
  • Karen Harper
  • Jude Deveraux

    Authors Others Love That I Don't


  • Bertrice Small
  • Susan Johnson
  • Linda Howard

    Most Annoying Lead Character


  • Mellyora MacAdin, Come the Morning by Shannon Drake

  • Favorite Romance Novels

    Absolute Favorites


  • Gone with the Wind
  • by Margaret Mitchell

    Favorite Classic


  • Sense and Sensibility
  • by Jane Austen

  • Favorites by Sub-Genre

    American Historical:


  • Morning Glory
  • by LaVyrle Spencer
  • Love Comes Softly
  • by Janette Oke
  • Rosewood
  • by Candice Camp

    European Historical:


  • Forever Amber
  • by Kathleen Windsor
  • Lord of the Night
  • by Susan Wiggs
  • Gypsy Baron
  • by Mary Daheim
  • Bridgerton Family Series
  • by Julia Quinn
  • The Blood of Roses
  • by Marsha Canham

    Regency:


  • The Grand Sophy
  • by Georgette Heyer
  • Isabella
  • by Janet Grace
  • The Emerald Necklace
  • by Diana Brown

    Medieval:


  • Tapestry
  • by Maura Seger
  • Child of Awe
  • by Kathryn Lynn Davis
  • A Falcon's Heart
  • by Jayel Wylie
  • Roselynde
  • by Roberta Gellis

    Alternate Reality:


  • In Death Series
  • by J.D. Robb

    Category:


  • A Rose for Maggie
  • by Kathleen Korbel
  • Break the Night
  • by Anne Stuart
  • Fear Familiar Series
  • by Caroline Burnes

  • Favorites by Plot Type

    Suspense:


  • Dr. Rhea Lynch Series
  • by Gwen Hunter
  • Daughter of the Game
  • by Tracy Grant
  • Be Buried in the Rain
  • by Barbara Michaels

    Cabin or Road:


  • The Cockermouth Mail
  • by Dinah Dean

    Funny:


  • How to Marry a Marquis
  • by Julia Quinn
  • Stephanie Plum Series
  • by Janet Evanovich

    Sexy:


  • A Dove at Midnight
  • by Rexanne Becnel

  • Favorites by Mood

    Comfort Reads:


  • Any earlier novels
  • by Amanda Quick or Susan Wiggs
  • Anything
  • by Julia Quinn

    Most-Hanky Reads:


  • To Love and To Cherish
  • by Patricia Gaffney

    Guilty Pleasures:


  • Velvet Quartet
  • by Jude Deveraux
  • No Gentle Love
  • by Rebecca Brandewyne

  • Non-Romance Favorites


    Favorite Author

  • William Shakespeare
  • Leo Tolstoy
  • Jane Austen
  • Barbara Tuchman

    Favorite Book

  • Don Quixote by Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra

    Favorite Classic Novel

  • Anna Karenina by Leo Tolstoy
  • The Grapes of Wrath by John Steinbeck
  • Emily of New Moon Trilogy by L.M. Montgomery

    Favorite Mystery

  • Mary Russell/Sherlock Holmes Series by Laurie King
  • An Unkindness of Ravens by Ruth Rendell

    Favorite SF/Fantasy

  • Neverwhere by Neil Gaiman
  • Beloved Exile by Parke Godwin


  • Favorite Women's Fiction

  • The Saving Graces by Patricia Gaffney
  • Bridget Jones's Diary by Helen Fielding

    Favorite YA Book

  • From the Mixed-up Files of Mrs. Basil E. Frankweiler by E.L. Konigsburg
  • The Witch of Blackbird Pond by Elizabeth George Speare
  • Step to the Music by Phyllis Whitney
  • Susannah by Candice F. Ransom

    Favorite Set of Connected Books

  • Morland Dynasty Series by Cynthia Harrod-Eagles
  • The Harry Potter Series by J.K. Rowling

    Book Most Often Reread

  • Anything by L.M. Montgomery
  • Child of Awe by Kathryn Lynn Davis
  • Too Deep for Tears by Kathryn Lynn Davis